Involving users in evaluation
Over the last few years ESS has been supporting third sector organisations to involve people they work with in evaluation.
In 2015 we developed a workbook 'Why bother involving people in evaluation? Beyond feedback' which came out of our work 'Support in the right direction'. More info here
Involving young people in evaluation (2018 - 2019)
ESS is working with the National Lottery Community Fund to provide learning and self-evaluation support to their grantholders in Scotland. This is the second phase of our learning programme on involving young people in planning or doing evaluation. We’ve learnt a lot from the first phase of the programme. We know that while it isn’t always smooth sailing, project leads have told us involving young people they support has helped their organisation as well as benefiting young people. Young people are fantastic evaluation problem solvers!
In the first phase, young people told us that getting involved in designing evaluation questions and methods was:
"It was an honour to be asked and included in something that is ultimately going to help future service users"
"I felt like this was good and it’s changed my view of what you guys do for us"
"Designing our own evaluations makes us feel good"
"I had fun!"
The project leads felt that by getting young people on board with shaping evaluation methods had helped them gather more authentic and richer feedback as well as increasing participation in evaluation.
Case studies from phase one:
Springhall and Whitlawburn Youth Development Team - Getting evaluation done without lots of moans and groans!
Gowrie Care's Streets Ahead service - The power of the emoji
In the second phase of the learning programme we are working with the following projects.
In June 2019 we came together and ran a learning session, where we supported project leads to develop an action plan, using Why bother involving people in evaluation - beyond feedback as a guide.
From June to November 2019 – project leads carry out their actions
In December 2019 we came back together for a sharing the learning session.
Case studies from phase two:
Young Movers - Championing evaluation
Beatroute Arts - Music to my ears
RASAC- PK -Youth Ambassadors leading on evaluation
SWYDT - Getting the balance right
You may also be interested in reading this NPC blog and resource about user involvement:
This workbook can help you plan why, when and how to involve the people you work with in evaluation.
Where We Belong, run by Beatroute Arts in Balornock in North East Glasgow provides young people from the area with ...
Rape and Sexual Abuse Centre Perth and Kinross (RASAC P&K) on how they involved their Youth Ambassadors to help evaluate ...
YoMo Health Champions show the benefits of involving young people in evaluation.
This paper from NPC argues for a greater focus in the charity sector on what user involvement aims to achieve, ...
Gowrie Care's Streets Ahead service show how the organisation involved their service users in evaluation.
Springhall and Whitlawburn Youth Development Team show how they involved young people in evaluation.
This case study shows how ARC Scotland involved service users in setting outcomes for service commissioning by Aberdeenshire Council. It ...
Young people taking the lead on evaluation - Key messages from 11th April 2019
Inspiring Impact has produced a guide to share examples and tips from organisations who involve their users in shaping their ...
A blog from Dawn Smith (Public Engagement Officer at Edinburgh Napier University) about the Scottish Co-Production Network's workshop on Evaluating ...
Springhall and Whitlawburn Youth Development Team has been supporting young people to take the lead on evaluation since 2018, with ...